I've suspected something along those lines,myself, but I'm very reluctant to mess about with the settings which have always worked before. There is a danger of upsetting all sorts of other things. TBH I've wasted two days on this already and as Peter said, it would have been much quicker to use a sheet of styrene, especially since I wasn't actually planning on doing anything to the roof originally until I had a 'good' idea!metalmuncher wrote: ↑Wed Jan 26, 2022 7:00 pm - more curing time for the bolt layers? Slower Z axis movement to make the peel less violent?
Printing thin resin sheets - NEW PROBLEM - finished
Re: Printing thin resin sheets
Philip
Re: Printing thin resin sheets - PROBLEM SOLVED
Following MetalMunchers prodding, above, and despite what I said, I decided to have a look at what settings can be changed.
I discovered a number of things. Firstly, that as I suspected i had no idea what most of the variables were, or at least what effect they actually had. Secondly, I found that it is easy to set up a new print profile and retain the original one, which relieved my mind more than somewhat.
I then went to the Anycubic support and looked at their recomended settings for their grey resin and compared them with the basic default settings that Chitubox has been using for the Photon-S. One thing jumped out at me and slightly put the wind up me, the Chitubox lift speed is 180mm/sec and the Anycubic figure is 3mm/sec! Not only is that a huge difference in itself, but it would increase print times by a factor of nearly 90!
So I went off looking at various forums and found a post by somebody who says he routinely uses the grey resin and has good success with various settings which he listed, the important ones being the exposure time of 16.5 sec compared to 8 seconds previously, and the lift speed of 30mm/sec. I found various other posts suggesting lift speeds in the 30-40mm/sec region, which gave a bit of confidence.
So I bit the bullet and copied his complete set of parameters as a new print profile, re-sliced it and pushed the button. It took 24minutes to print what was previously taking 11minutes, but it came out perfectly first go!
Of course these thin sheets are only 1.25mm high so quick to print by any standards. Anything very tall would start adding very significant time to the print, so I don't think I shall change to this as a default, but I might play around for a compromise. The thing is that it is only a couple of clicks to switch between saved profiles at the slicing stage, so no problems there.
Thanks for the prodding Richard.
I discovered a number of things. Firstly, that as I suspected i had no idea what most of the variables were, or at least what effect they actually had. Secondly, I found that it is easy to set up a new print profile and retain the original one, which relieved my mind more than somewhat.
I then went to the Anycubic support and looked at their recomended settings for their grey resin and compared them with the basic default settings that Chitubox has been using for the Photon-S. One thing jumped out at me and slightly put the wind up me, the Chitubox lift speed is 180mm/sec and the Anycubic figure is 3mm/sec! Not only is that a huge difference in itself, but it would increase print times by a factor of nearly 90!
So I went off looking at various forums and found a post by somebody who says he routinely uses the grey resin and has good success with various settings which he listed, the important ones being the exposure time of 16.5 sec compared to 8 seconds previously, and the lift speed of 30mm/sec. I found various other posts suggesting lift speeds in the 30-40mm/sec region, which gave a bit of confidence.
So I bit the bullet and copied his complete set of parameters as a new print profile, re-sliced it and pushed the button. It took 24minutes to print what was previously taking 11minutes, but it came out perfectly first go!
Of course these thin sheets are only 1.25mm high so quick to print by any standards. Anything very tall would start adding very significant time to the print, so I don't think I shall change to this as a default, but I might play around for a compromise. The thing is that it is only a couple of clicks to switch between saved profiles at the slicing stage, so no problems there.
Thanks for the prodding Richard.
Philip
Re: Printing thin resin sheets - PROBLEM SOLVED
That is good news, great teamwork and shows how useful the forum can be.
Like you, I generally stick with the default settings for my printing and only tinker when it's absolutely essential. It's disturbing, though, the difference between the default and the recommended setting for AnyCubic's own brand resin.
I've not used my resin printer for a while ( we're having a new kitchen and I stupidly said I'd do all the prep work ..... Don't ask me about lifting ceramic floor tiles!!!! ..... ), but next time I fire it up I'll take a look at its settings.
Rik
Like you, I generally stick with the default settings for my printing and only tinker when it's absolutely essential. It's disturbing, though, the difference between the default and the recommended setting for AnyCubic's own brand resin.
I've not used my resin printer for a while ( we're having a new kitchen and I stupidly said I'd do all the prep work ..... Don't ask me about lifting ceramic floor tiles!!!! ..... ), but next time I fire it up I'll take a look at its settings.
Rik
Re: Printing thin resin sheets - PROBLEM SOLVED
The settings are in Chitubox, not actually the printer - it's the "Settings" button just above the "Save" button after slicing. I suspect that Chitubox used some best guesses/middle of the road figures, plus the machine comes with the translucent resin and there are differences between translucent and coloured ( which I've ignored up to now!). The machine does a beautiful job of that lattice cube test print file using the translucent resin, we have both seen that at the beginning, so 180mm/sec lift is obviously spot on for that.
What is more concerning is the 3mm/sec lift that Anycubic state for the grey, which is plainly ridiculous. I suspect it could be a typo and should be 30 not 3, but Chinese proof readers can't tell the difference!
Philip
-
- Cleaner
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2012 4:15 pm
Re: Printing thin resin sheets - PROBLEM SOLVED
Glad you managed to sort it. I want to get into resin printing this year - built a new shed last year so I can get one without stinking up the house with resin and alcohol. I enjoyed toying with my filament printer over the past few years, now its probably tuned within an inch of its life, pretty reliable and fast, but I think with the messiness I'd want a resin printer to just work without much tweaking.
Just a note on the lift speeds, I wonder if there is some confusing of mm/s and mm/minute somewhere. 3mm/s is the same as 180mm/min. Have to be careful of this in filament printing, the slicer normally has settings in mm/s, but the gcode/printer itself generally understands mm/min, so the slicer multiplies the set value by 60 when generating the gcode.
Just a note on the lift speeds, I wonder if there is some confusing of mm/s and mm/minute somewhere. 3mm/s is the same as 180mm/min. Have to be careful of this in filament printing, the slicer normally has settings in mm/s, but the gcode/printer itself generally understands mm/min, so the slicer multiplies the set value by 60 when generating the gcode.
- -steves-
- Administrator
- Posts: 2445
- Joined: Thu Jul 28, 2011 1:50 pm
- Location: Cambridge & Peterborough
Re: Printing thin resin sheets - PROBLEM SOLVED
I had a look at my settings which I print any colour in and never get bad results. One is the Photon S, the other is a Photon Mono. Speed difference is massive, but both work perfectly. I am surprised by how slow you had to lift away to get it to work.
The buck stops here .......
Ditton Meadow Light Railway (DMLR)
Member of Peterborough and District Association
http://peterborough.16mm.org.uk/
Ditton Meadow Light Railway (DMLR)
Member of Peterborough and District Association
http://peterborough.16mm.org.uk/
Re: Printing thin resin sheets - PROBLEM SOLVED
Top are the default settings that Chitubox decided on when I first got my Photon-S and won't print my bolts on the sheet.
Bottom are the settings I got from somebody on a Photon forum, that has worked. That isn't to say that there isn't something somewhere in between
Richard could be right about me getting confused between mm/sec and mm/min though!
Bottom are the settings I got from somebody on a Photon forum, that has worked. That isn't to say that there isn't something somewhere in between
Richard could be right about me getting confused between mm/sec and mm/min though!
Philip
Re: Printing thin resin sheets - NEW PROBLEM
Actually this isn't about thin sheets, but it does follow on.
Yesterday evening I tried printing a driver for the wee beastie. I used the same settings that worked for the flat sheet but did increase the lift times a little. What I got was a complete disaster! Basically the model pulled awy from the supports so I ended up with a flattened misshapen head and one leg degenerated into a flat sheet.
Sooo... this morning I copied Steve's settings from the screenshot above... and this time, this is what I've just taken off:
Which is, give or take, the same as I got yesterday. I don't understand it, because I've printed plenty of figures, flat sheets, and small parts in the past, using the default settings which are effectively the same as Steve's, and never had anything like these problems.
The only thing I can think of is that it is duff resin, but as I said above, it's a new bottle and the problems started with the old bottle. Anyway, I've just ordered a bottle of the Anycubic clear green, which is what came with the machine originally and I'll see if that is any better.
Yesterday evening I tried printing a driver for the wee beastie. I used the same settings that worked for the flat sheet but did increase the lift times a little. What I got was a complete disaster! Basically the model pulled awy from the supports so I ended up with a flattened misshapen head and one leg degenerated into a flat sheet.
Sooo... this morning I copied Steve's settings from the screenshot above... and this time, this is what I've just taken off:
Which is, give or take, the same as I got yesterday. I don't understand it, because I've printed plenty of figures, flat sheets, and small parts in the past, using the default settings which are effectively the same as Steve's, and never had anything like these problems.
The only thing I can think of is that it is duff resin, but as I said above, it's a new bottle and the problems started with the old bottle. Anyway, I've just ordered a bottle of the Anycubic clear green, which is what came with the machine originally and I'll see if that is any better.
Philip
-
- Trainee Driver
- Posts: 988
- Joined: Fri Oct 05, 2018 6:30 pm
- Location: South West Wales
Re: Printing thin resin sheets - NEW PROBLEM
I have had similar problems printing figures in the past - not necessarily with the same resin but similar problems.
Let me explain what I think might be happening:
When you look at the planes which would be printed at each layer there are large flat areas which are being printed at perhaps the point where the figure has parted from the supports. To begin with it is printing only the middle of the body. The middle of the body has stuck to the supports and then as you go up the layers the area being printed at one time gets bigger and bigger, until by the time we get to the head and leg it is the whole longitudinal cross section of the figure which is being printed at once. The force holding the layer just printed to the bottom of the tank is now overcoming the force holding it to the supports.
What I did when I had this issue was I tilted the figure at say 30 degrees so that the head was significantly higher then the feet. When it is printed like this the maximum area being printed at any one time is much less - as it is taking a slice across the figure at 30 degrees. That now means that the "stiction" force between the printed plane and the tank bottom is much less.
I sometimes use thicker supports for the parts further from the plate as well.
Trevor
Let me explain what I think might be happening:
When you look at the planes which would be printed at each layer there are large flat areas which are being printed at perhaps the point where the figure has parted from the supports. To begin with it is printing only the middle of the body. The middle of the body has stuck to the supports and then as you go up the layers the area being printed at one time gets bigger and bigger, until by the time we get to the head and leg it is the whole longitudinal cross section of the figure which is being printed at once. The force holding the layer just printed to the bottom of the tank is now overcoming the force holding it to the supports.
What I did when I had this issue was I tilted the figure at say 30 degrees so that the head was significantly higher then the feet. When it is printed like this the maximum area being printed at any one time is much less - as it is taking a slice across the figure at 30 degrees. That now means that the "stiction" force between the printed plane and the tank bottom is much less.
I sometimes use thicker supports for the parts further from the plate as well.
Trevor
Re: Printing thin resin sheets - NEW PROBLEM
Thanks Trevor, that does make a lot of sense and I'll look into it. Instinct is to try to get it as flat as poss on the bed so that the print time is cut down, but it's a false economy if I have to print several copies to get one good one.
However, this afternoon I switched from the grey resin to some black but changed nothing else, and as far as I can see it has printed perfectly. I've had my suspicions about this bottle of grey for several days and I'm more than ever suspicious now. It's only a week old and has a Use By date in 2024.
It's the driver I've been struggling with and he is still on his supports, but I've got his mate on the printer now, should be done by bedtime and then we'll know...
Re supports, I normally use the "Heavy" ones, only occasionally going to Light for things like fingers, if necessary.
However, this afternoon I switched from the grey resin to some black but changed nothing else, and as far as I can see it has printed perfectly. I've had my suspicions about this bottle of grey for several days and I'm more than ever suspicious now. It's only a week old and has a Use By date in 2024.
It's the driver I've been struggling with and he is still on his supports, but I've got his mate on the printer now, should be done by bedtime and then we'll know...
Re supports, I normally use the "Heavy" ones, only occasionally going to Light for things like fingers, if necessary.
Philip
Re: Printing thin resin sheets - NEW PROBLEM
Well, I've now printed 4 figures using the Anycubic Black and all have come out perfectly, so I have to put all of my problems down to the grey resin. A relief in one way that it isn't my drawing or the machine, but an absolute pain having to throw away nearly a litre of resin. It isn't worth messing about with it anymore after all the problems with the riveted sheets and the figures, plus the fact that it didn't cure properly either. I've had a sheet with missing rivets sitting on the window cill facing the afternoon sun ( what there is of it) for 5 days and the surface is still tacky.
Philip
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests