Garden Railway Forum

Peter Butler wrote: ↑Sat Jun 29, 2024 7:17 pm Wow.... that was a close one!... Many thanks to all who voted for me and I also send commiserations to Aaron for trailing by just one vote. That is a wonderful structure Aaron and I would not have been disappointed to lose to you for that entry.
I will now try to think of a suitable subject for the next one.

It's rare to wish one had the opportunity to vote for two entries, but this was one such occasion. In the end it was the overall setting which tipped me to voting for Peter's entry.
Well done to all who took part!

Well it was a fairly close vote between Rik and errrr.... Rik!
So I officially declare Rik to be the winner this quarter, with his entry:

Barclay 2-4-0T loco No. 2 BEESTON, brings bricks to Bulkeley Boneworks for a new bunker for the beam engine
Well done Rik.
Please may I ask you to PM me with your theme for the next quarter, asap? Ta!

Congratulations Rik, and commiserations to... Rik!

I would like to say thanks to everyone who entered this thread and embraced the spirit of fun. That is how life should be.

Peter.

Peter Butler wrote: ↑Mon Sep 16, 2024 11:10 am Congratulations Rik, and commiserations to... Rik!

I would like to say thanks to everyone who entered this thread and embraced the spirit of fun. That is how life should be.

Peter.

Thanks for providing such an inspirational theme - you'll notice I've borrowed your idea for the next Gallery theme. I consulted an online glossary of railway terminology, and S was the section with the most entries (followed closely by C). So hopefully, plenty of scope for sensational, surprisingly successful snapping....?

Rik

Any of my model photos, if successful, are surprising..


Phil.P

OK...now we have a conundrum....this quarters results were very very close with THREE entries getting 3 votes each and 4 more very close behind with 2 votes each.

So, this quarters winners are:
greh Peter Butler Tropic Blunder Well done to all of you and thanks to all who entered and to those who bothered to vote.

However, I'm not too sure how we get out of this without having run-off vote, which seems a bit of a sledgehammer to crack a nut. Alternatively I could just give myself the casting vote, but I really don't want to do that.
Instead, if the three winners would all PM me with a theme for the next Gallery please, I'll make the choice of which one we go for. So if you three would let me have your proposals on or before New Years Day, please, that would be good.

Hi Philip,
in the spirit of Christmas, and as I have won previously, I will gladly withdraw from the contest and let others have a chance.

Ok, Peter, thanks. Well, if you are sure, it looks like an all Aussie choice then!

Congratulations to the winners, and good show to everyone else who entered. It was a tough choice who to vote for this round!

All worthy winners. No reason why we can't have two themes for the next competition with members submitting their photos to either or both as we each can submit two photos.

Rik

Given that Greg was one of my biggest inspirations growing up modelling Australian 1:24 stuff I'm also happy to withdraw to the very nice shot of the iconic Sandstone Station with the 20 and CPH sitting in front capturing that very blue mountains flavour. Congrats Greg Looking forward to seeing what the next theme will be!

Well after Peter and Graeme have both chickened out, it looks like you have drawn the short straw Greg
So if you would PM me your suggestion asap, we'll get it rolling.

...and a Happy New Year!!

Tropic Blunder wrote: ↑Thu Dec 26, 2024 9:47 am Given that Greg was one of my biggest inspirations growing up modelling Australian 1:24 stuff I'm also happy to withdraw to the very nice shot of the iconic Sandstone Station with the 20 and CPH sitting in front capturing that very blue mountains flavour. Congrats Greg Looking forward to seeing what the next theme will be!

Wow, thanks for that. I never realised that anyone took notice of the SaTR. Coming from you, it is high praise. I always wait for your videos to pop up. And I was going to defer to your topic idea but I was too slow!
Now to think of a topic - not easy after the Christmas cheer.

philipy wrote: ↑Wed Dec 25, 2024 9:16 am OK...now we have a conundrum....this quarters results were very very close with THREE entries getting 3 votes each...

My fault... I voted for a different photo...
Congratulations to Greg, Peter and Jake!

I'm afraid that I have to report that the clear winner this quarter is...me!
I can't quite believe that it was such a clear vote, there are other bridge pictures that I personally thought more worthy, but thank you to those who did vote for my entry.
I have a theme in mind for the next Gallery, which I'll post shortly, as usual.

Too modest Philip, a clear winner in my opinion.

It takes years of soft rain to grow moss like that..
There are two bridges in the picture, as well..


Phil.P

Phil.P wrote: ↑Sun Mar 16, 2025 4:36 pm
There are two bridges in the picture, as well..

There are indeed. My original caption on the entry photo was, "Octavius on a short goods crossing the Cuttle Brook bridge ( with Solstice Cottage footbridge in the background)"

Phil.P wrote: ↑Sun Mar 16, 2025 4:36 pm It takes years of soft rain to grow moss like that..
There are two bridges in the picture, as well..

Quality & quantity!

SimonWood wrote: ↑Mon Mar 17, 2025 11:19 am Quality & quantity!

And you don't see that, much.