Barton Hill extension
Barton Hill extension
In case any of you are wondering, the big hole is for a turntable to drop in. I thought it would be a good idea to have it easily removable rather than let it suffer the ravages of the winter weather. The dark coloured material is recycled plastic from Filcris and the lighter coloured material on the top is a recycled plastic/bamboo composite from Wickes, time will tell how effective this combination will be.
I will be ballasting the track with chicken grit which I think looks quite in keeping with scale and easily available and cheap. Now for some advice from you guys, I have been following all the various threads on here about the trials and tribulations of using SBR to secure the ballast and I believe that it is probably the way to go. However looking at various suppliers it seems that the smallest quantity available is 5ltrs, is this what most people have found? Not really a problem but then further research tells me that it's generally only got a shelf life of one year, which means I'll end up with a quantity left over which won't store for long.
Phil
Re: Barton Hill extension
Looking good so far Phil.
My SBR is certainly in a 5ltr container. I'd never looked at the storage instructions before now, but you're right it does say 12months in a cool place above 5degrees C, and protect from frost. I've had it for 3 or 4 years and it still works fine and there is about 1/4 of the bottle left. I keep it in an unheated garden shed which freezes in winter and boils in summer, so I wouldn't worry too much. I did some fairly major ballast patching in my station area on Friday afternoon and it was solid as a rock on Saturday morning. There are a few soft lumps in the bottle but they aren't a problem.
My SBR is certainly in a 5ltr container. I'd never looked at the storage instructions before now, but you're right it does say 12months in a cool place above 5degrees C, and protect from frost. I've had it for 3 or 4 years and it still works fine and there is about 1/4 of the bottle left. I keep it in an unheated garden shed which freezes in winter and boils in summer, so I wouldn't worry too much. I did some fairly major ballast patching in my station area on Friday afternoon and it was solid as a rock on Saturday morning. There are a few soft lumps in the bottle but they aren't a problem.
Philip
Re: Barton Hill extension
Yes, Don't worry about it - basically - what Philipy says
Phil
Sporadic Garden Railer who's inconsistencies know no bounds
My Line - https://gardenrails.org/forum/viewtopic ... 41&t=11077
Sporadic Garden Railer who's inconsistencies know no bounds
My Line - https://gardenrails.org/forum/viewtopic ... 41&t=11077
Re: Barton Hill extension
I'll be interested to see how durable the Wickes plastic/bamboo combo is. I presume it is cheaper than Filcris?
Ian
Re: Barton Hill extension
Yes it is cheaper, but the main reason I used it is because of its size. It is ideal for what I wanted as a top surface to the "baseboard". Also not visible are small gaps between the planks to allow for water drainage. As you say time will tell but I honestly don't think that any potential deterioration will be a problem in my lifetime.
Phil
Re: Barton Hill extension
I picked up some SBR from Toolstation this morning, so if the weather behaves this week I will begin experimenting with ballasting using the chicken grit that I've got, apart from a few pieces of oyster shell in the mix I think it looks a very realistic size ballast. As I mentioned previously the planks have small gaps between them to allow for some drainage but I'm now wondering if the SBR is going to negate this idea. Possibly I should think about some other form of drainage maybe miniature trackside drains in the cessation - I am joking (I think). What's the general feeling of the experts on this illustrious forum?
Phil
- Peter Butler
- Driver
- Posts: 5266
- Joined: Sun Sep 09, 2012 10:33 pm
- Location: West Wales
Re: Barton Hill extension
I'm no expert but drains are certainly possible..... this is how I fitted mine as the concrete foundations and roadway had no alternative to release rainwater....
The best things in life are free.... so why am I doing this?
- tom_tom_go
- Driver
- Posts: 4824
- Joined: Wed Feb 23, 2011 3:08 am
- Location: Kent, UK
- Contact:
Re: Barton Hill extension
If you are going to use SBR then the drainage gaps you have left won't do anything as the ballast will become hard and resist water.
Do you need to fix the ballast in place as you are boxing the track in?
Do you need to fix the ballast in place as you are boxing the track in?
Re: Barton Hill extension
Peter, those drain gratings look brilliant did you produce them yourself or are they some kind of commercial item?
Tom, I really do need to fix the ballast as the local birdlife i.e. pigeons and blackbirds will be scattering it in all directions otherwise. I have covered the ground underneath my "baseboard" with 20mm ballast and the blackbirds even manage to throw that around in their quest for food, so goodness knows what they would manage to do with the smaller particles of chicken grit.
I will continue to ponder this issue over the next few days whilst I run some trains to prove the track arrangement.
Tom, I really do need to fix the ballast as the local birdlife i.e. pigeons and blackbirds will be scattering it in all directions otherwise. I have covered the ground underneath my "baseboard" with 20mm ballast and the blackbirds even manage to throw that around in their quest for food, so goodness knows what they would manage to do with the smaller particles of chicken grit.
I will continue to ponder this issue over the next few days whilst I run some trains to prove the track arrangement.
Phil
Re: Barton Hill extension
Phil, not wishing to answer for Peter but I believe he had them made.
However I do have one of these in stock somewhere ( can't find it at the mo though) from a kitchen job I was going to do but didn't!
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Brown-Air-Ve ... 0005.m1851
They come in different sizes and I'm sure could be cut to fit individual drains. I think they can also be had in other standard colours
Philip
Re: Barton Hill extension
Just to add my two penn'orth Phil (and add another Phil to the mix )-
You could stil ballast with SBR, and either leave small holes at the board junctions to act as drains, or simply drill through the set SBR on the board junctions afterwards.
You could stil ballast with SBR, and either leave small holes at the board junctions to act as drains, or simply drill through the set SBR on the board junctions afterwards.
Phil
Sporadic Garden Railer who's inconsistencies know no bounds
My Line - https://gardenrails.org/forum/viewtopic ... 41&t=11077
Sporadic Garden Railer who's inconsistencies know no bounds
My Line - https://gardenrails.org/forum/viewtopic ... 41&t=11077
- Peter Butler
- Driver
- Posts: 5266
- Joined: Sun Sep 09, 2012 10:33 pm
- Location: West Wales
Re: Barton Hill extension
Correct Philip, a friend with a milling machine made them from solid alloy material for me, not commercially available. I like the idea of your kitchen grilles, trimmed to size they would do the job equally well.
The best things in life are free.... so why am I doing this?
Re: Barton Hill extension
Thanks to you all for all the good ideas.
Today I thought that I would begin my experiments with the SBR so get every thing out ready and it then starts to rain . Oh well I can't win them all. But realistically I suppose it isn't the best time of year to do something like this, maybe I will turn my attention to the remote operation of the points as I now have all the materials to hand.
Today I thought that I would begin my experiments with the SBR so get every thing out ready and it then starts to rain . Oh well I can't win them all. But realistically I suppose it isn't the best time of year to do something like this, maybe I will turn my attention to the remote operation of the points as I now have all the materials to hand.
Phil
Re: Barton Hill extension
The short spur running off the turntable will eventually have a buffer stop mounted on it to hopefully prevent any runaways. I have arranged it so that the whole turntable lifts out of the baseboard for storage and has thus saved me having to drill any drainage holes in the well of the turntable, which I don't think would look very prototypical.
Phil
Re: Barton Hill extension
Interesting photos of the SS turntable, of which I have one waiting for me to get the "urge"...
I notice that you've left the rails longer than the bridge-plate, I was thinking the same.
I will be drilling a few drainage holes in my turntable base. However, I reckon that the turntable will spend most of its life in the same position and the bridge-plate will cover the holes.
I notice that you've left the rails longer than the bridge-plate, I was thinking the same.
I will be drilling a few drainage holes in my turntable base. However, I reckon that the turntable will spend most of its life in the same position and the bridge-plate will cover the holes.
Re: Barton Hill extension
Andrew, yes I left the rails long on the turntable deliberately as in my case I intend to remove it after each operating session and that would not be possible if the trackside rails ran over the t/t masonry. Also theoretically it should allow for longer engines to be turned.
Phil
Re: Barton Hill extension
Thanks Phil,
I've just noticed the rail chairs securing the rail (rather than sleepers), looks much better IMO?
What chairs are they, assuming that they are a commercial item?
I've just noticed the rail chairs securing the rail (rather than sleepers), looks much better IMO?
What chairs are they, assuming that they are a commercial item?
Re: Barton Hill extension
Indeed they are commercial - standard Peco chairs (usual disclaimer). I also thought that sleepers on what is supposed to be a steel deck just didn't look right, so as I had a number of the Peco chairs left over from my brief brush with turnout construction I used those. They are secured to the deck with an epoxy resin which I trust will be satisfactory as it won't be exposed to any weather as I intend to bring the t/t inside after any operating session.
Phil
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest