Just kidding, the pot is made up of two halves.
This is an old Märklin acid pot wagon.
I only have one pot. The wagon holds four.
Could anyone draw up a 3D model so I could have some more printed?
Exact dimensions will be provided.
- Posts: 1791
- Joined: Thu Jul 28, 2011 1:50 pm
- Location: Cambridge & Peterborough
It was difficult to measure as the sides are curved.
These are the main dimensions (in mm):
and another picture to show the profile:
I do not need a 100% match. It should just look right from normal viewing distance.
Then I simply joined up the curves with straight lines for the sides and base, so that I ended up with a flat outline of half of the vessel. You can see the black lines on the LH photo on my post above. Next I drew a 9mm radius circle at right angles at the base, selected the edge of the circle, selected the "follow me" tool and clicked on the shape and it instantly rotated it to give the completed vessel.
If you want a more graphical explanation I'll try to do a series of stills.
One thing I should say is that at present it is completely solid, because I didn't want to mess about with hollowing it until I was sure you liked the shape, but that shouldn't be too much of a problem to do before producing the stl's
For printing it, personally I'd try a resin printer ideally, but if you want to use fdm, I very much doubt you would get away with less than 1mm thick walls and you might have to go to 1.5. Having said that, do you really need them completely hollow? Because if they were solid up to a couple of mm below the neck you might have more chance of "balancing" a thin neck on top, if you see what I mean, and painted matt black inside it would hardly be noticeable. I could taper the edge of the neck down to say 0.5 mm but no guarantees that it would print properly, that will depend on your slicer and printer settings, I think.
I know you wanted three of these to match the metal original, but in terms of consistency, you might want to print four and put your original away somewhere for the future, because they won't look absolutely identical.
BTW, do you want an indication of the central horizontal seam, or is that just where the originals are joined in two halves?
Lemme know what you think?
the seam is optional.
I am planning to have some more printed. some will be "stored" on a pallet as replacements.
A friend has a resin printer, so this could be done without problems.
Just leave the top 2 mm open.
I have never used Sketchup. Might be worth looking at.
I'm not sure about the straightness of the sides, it looks as though perhaps it ought to be a bit more bulbous in the centre? If you want me to adjust it, just say.
I've used Sketchup for years and am used to it's quirks, but Rik couldn't get on with it at all, although Trevor uses it. Also, I use the PC standalone 2017 version, which is obsolete. They stopped supporting it several years ago and you have to sign up for the (free) cloud version. Thats fine as long as there is a good net connection, but any probs with your phones and ....!
- Trainee Driver
- Posts: 693
- Joined: Fri Oct 05, 2018 6:30 pm
- Location: South West Wales
Having said that I got it to work on one occasion - but couldn't repeat it!
As Philip said I use sketchup the same 2017 version on an iMac - but it took me a long time to really understand it.
Glad to see that Philip has solved it for you.
TinkerCAD came to my rescue. As a former primary school teacher, it probably helps that TinkerCAD is designed for kids to use. Touch wood, with TinkerCAD, I've not (yet) had one shape which Cura has rejected despite having drawn and printed around 700 different shapes.
However, it's not as versatile as SketchUp, especially with complex curved shapes like this.
Pots look good and have the right shape.
Something must have gone wrong during the data conversion as it is too big by a factor of 1.4.
Will look into it and show pics after the right size has been printed.
No idea about the sizing problem, but assuming your mate is using Chitubox to slice, it is easy to scale it by the correct factor first. Other slicers almost certainly have a similar function so it shouldn't be a big deal.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests