Forward and Reverse noise

Anything related to the garden railway world that is not catered for in another board
Post Reply
frank3447
Cleaner
Cleaner
Posts: 18
Joined: Sun Oct 13, 2019 5:46 pm

Forward and Reverse noise

Post by frank3447 » Sat Apr 09, 2022 5:49 pm

Hi.
Can anybody throw some light on why some of my 16mm scratch-built electric diesel's in one direction it's very noisy but when switched to the opposite direction it's quiet, I use MFA motors and the usual brass worm and drive gears? Thanks, Frank.

User avatar
Lonsdaler
Driver
Driver
Posts: 1226
Joined: Tue May 20, 2014 9:50 am
Location: North Yorkshire

Re: Forward and Reverse noise

Post by Lonsdaler » Sun Apr 10, 2022 10:07 am

Hi Frank,
Do you run your locos mostly in one direction and only occasionally in the other? I'm wondering if the problem is a function of 'wear' or 'running in'.
There are more knowledgeable people on here with experience of electric motor running who I am sure will chime in currently, but more information may be helpful to them also.
Phil

Sporadic Garden Railer who's inconsistencies know no bounds

My Line - https://gardenrails.org/forum/viewtopic ... 41&t=11077

User avatar
Peter Butler
Driver
Driver
Posts: 5219
Joined: Sun Sep 09, 2012 10:33 pm
Location: West Wales

Re: Forward and Reverse noise

Post by Peter Butler » Sun Apr 10, 2022 10:33 am

Hi Frank, you are not alone in this matter.
All of my locomotives are battery operated with a variety of electric motors and many of them suffer from the same condition. Whether it is the meshing of the gears or some other rubbing/grinding I have never discovered. No doubt someone has done a study.
Interesting you mention it regarding scratch-built models, does it not happen on others too?
The best things in life are free.... so why am I doing this?

frank3447
Cleaner
Cleaner
Posts: 18
Joined: Sun Oct 13, 2019 5:46 pm

Re: Forward and Reverse noise

Post by frank3447 » Sun Apr 10, 2022 10:47 am

Hello Phil.
Thanks for your helpful reply. I took another long look at the worm gear on the motor shaft and could see slight movement when the motor is switched between forward and reverse so I moved the worm gear further along the shaft from the motor and no more noise :D :D :D Perhaps some motors shafts move more than others when put in forward and reverse you get what you pay for I shall investigate more. Hope this helps other enthusiasts. Frank.

User avatar
-steves-
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 2412
Joined: Thu Jul 28, 2011 1:50 pm
Location: Cambridge & Peterborough

Re: Forward and Reverse noise

Post by -steves- » Sun Apr 10, 2022 11:05 am

A worm gear although it will run on a 90 degree flat drive gear, because of the angle of the worm gear is cut actually runs much smoother when set at the same angle as the worm "tooth". I found this out by printing a rail car from Thingiverse and it took me a while to work out why he had offset the motor at a slight angle, the result, perfect silent running backwards and forwards. It makes sense when you think about it.

Just to conform I have exactly the same problem with most of my electric locos and most of those are on brand new gears. I will be trying my own offset motor at some point on a future loco to see if I get the same results.
The buck stops here .......

Ditton Meadow Light Railway (DMLR)
Member of Peterborough and District Association
http://peterborough.16mm.org.uk/

User avatar
GTB
Driver
Driver
Posts: 1550
Joined: Sat Mar 05, 2011 2:46 pm
Location: Australia

Re: Forward and Reverse noise

Post by GTB » Sun Apr 10, 2022 12:38 pm

frank3447 wrote: Sun Apr 10, 2022 10:47 am I took another long look at the worm gear on the motor shaft and could see slight movement when the motor is switched between forward and reverse so I moved the worm gear further along the shaft from the motor and no more noise.
As you found, end float in the motor shaft is the usual cause of more noise in one direction than the other. Wear and/or poor meshing is more likely to make the gears noisy in both directions.

Worm gear sets need to have thrust control on the worm shaft so that there is minimal longitudinal movement of the worm, but it is still able to rotate freely.

Worm drives generate high end thrust on the worm shaft. Most of the small motors used in models have no control of longitudinal movement of the armature shaft and the bearings aren't designed to take end loading. So this has to be done with some form of thrust control on the worm. I checked a MFA-Como 385 motor I have in stock as a spare and the armature shaft has about half a mm of end float.

Also worms are meant to mesh with a matching worm wheel, which has the teeth cut at an angle and hollowed to wrap partially around the worm. They aren't intended to be used with straight cut spur gears as often found in cheap toy drives, which leads to high tooth loading and rapid wear. Worm drives aren't particularly efficient as the teeth have to slide against each other, rather than the rolling contact of properly made spur gears, so some power is lost in the worm drive.

I've lived with worm drives in HO scale models due to the compact size, but I try to use gearboxes if at all possible. In large scale space isn't such an issue and I prefer to use gear motors with closed gearboxes and mitre gear final drives. My battery electric models are quiet enough out on the track, that the metal wheels of the train running on metal rails make more noise than the loco.

Regards,
Graeme

User avatar
Lonsdaler
Driver
Driver
Posts: 1226
Joined: Tue May 20, 2014 9:50 am
Location: North Yorkshire

Re: Forward and Reverse noise

Post by Lonsdaler » Sun Apr 10, 2022 5:53 pm

frank3447 wrote: Sun Apr 10, 2022 10:47 am Hello Phil.
Thanks for your helpful reply. I took another long look at the worm gear on the motor shaft and could see slight movement when the motor is switched between forward and reverse so I moved the worm gear further along the shaft from the motor and no more noise :D :D :D Perhaps some motors shafts move more than others when put in forward and reverse you get what you pay for I shall investigate more. Hope this helps other enthusiasts. Frank.
Glad you managed to sort it Frank. And like I suggested, loads of other helpful advice from our good members too.👍
Phil

Sporadic Garden Railer who's inconsistencies know no bounds

My Line - https://gardenrails.org/forum/viewtopic ... 41&t=11077

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests