3 D Printing 16mm models

[Peter Butler]

That looks really good Rik, not too much cleaning up required according to the pictures.... the camera never lies; does it?
I certainly agree about not printing plain, flat areas, it s easier and quicker to cut HIP for that.

[philipy]

That is very nice Rik, well done.

I have printed wheels once, in ABS. They look fine but I've never actually incorporated them in a model because I had ( have?) the same reservations. Also of course they have no weight in adhesion terms.

[Trevor Thompson]

Ah wheels!

I have gone over entirely to printing wheels - apart for those for live steam models.

I have complete control over the diameter, spoke arrangement and profile. I can even experiment with non standard wheel profiles knowing I can just throw them away if they don't work out.

The only issue is to ensure that they run true on the axles. I have plenty ( a large pile ) of wheels which didn't run true because I didn't draw them the correct way. I am fairly confident that I can now get 85% of the wheels to run true, but I still get some that wobble on the axle and I don't know why. I make them all the same way from the same files, and ream them in the lathe, as well as pressing the axles on in the lathe.

I don't see why plastic wheels commercially made should be acceptable and the ones I print at home shouldn't be. If they run true and are round that is!

I am also printing chopper couplings and they seem fine. Even the hooks work - although I am quite prepared to make them from brass if the plastic ones break (which seems quite likely).

4415, the wren, the coaches and the wagons I have described are all running on printed wheels. They work fine as far as I can see so far!

Floors and roofs? I have been printing those as well. I agree that it might be just as easy to use plastic sheet. I would have to buy that though. If the floor incorporates the framework then the complete wagon base can be printed in one go. The printed roof also has the correct profile - and actually the roof is the easy bit. On its end it prints really well. All those models mentioned in the last paragraph have printed roofs.

Trevor

Oh I also think that wagon is pretty good Rick.

[Trevor Thompson]

Latest printing progress.

The couplings for Linda ( see thread in the live steam section):

IMG_1028.jpg (312.48 KiB) Viewed 4306 times

I am sure those hooks will fail eventually - but lets see how long they last! The BIG advantage is that every coupling is the same. They will all engage accurately. I am standardising on these for locos and coaches. They also connect to wagons with the correct wagon couplings.

And the station building has all its walls assembled:

IMG_1027.jpg (313.38 KiB) Viewed 4306 times

IMG_1026.jpg (338.82 KiB) Viewed 4306 times

It is amazing how large a scale model of something real actually is! Internal walls and ceilings are to be added not for appearance but to impart rigidity to the model.

Trevor

[ge_rik]

Those choppers look well engineered. Are they sprung to return to centre?

Rik

[Trevor Thompson]

No they just lie where they want to. Doesn't seem a problem.

Trevor

[Trevor Thompson]

I have fitted skeleton internal walls and skeleton ceilings into the station building to stiffen it.

I am now in the process of printing and fitting roof trusses into position:

IMG_1039.jpg (349.01 KiB) Viewed 4224 times

and I have started to detail the roof sections prior to printing:

Screen Shot 2020-11-09 at 21.32.23.png (368.11 KiB) Viewed 4224 times

Trevor

[Trevor Thompson]

The roof trusses are all finished and installed:

IMG_1053.jpg (304.25 KiB) Viewed 4165 times

and I have updated the slate profile to agree with the photos:

Screen Shot 2020-11-11 at 18.23.01.png (375.69 KiB) Viewed 4165 times

First roof section is now printing. It will take 9 hours.

As an aside I have just started to use a new supply of ABS filament. It is from a different supplier and it seems to be printing at a lower temperature and more reliably. Perhaps I should stick to this supplier in future!

Trevor

[Tropic Blunder]

That van looks the bees knees Rik very clean printing on the planks with little stiration im very impressed. Trevor your buildings fantastic! what temp are you printing that ABS at?

[Trevor Thompson]

That van looks the bees knees Rik very clean printing on the planks with little stiration im very impressed. Trevor your buildings fantastic! what temp are you printing that ABS at?

I am printing it with the extruder at 225 degrees, and the bed at 100 degrees. That is dependent on the source of the filament. I was having problems printing the previous reel of white ABS with the extruder at 235 degrees.

I also think Riks van looks very crisply printed - is that the new printer Rik?

Trevor

[ge_rik]

...... - is that the new printer Rik?

Hi Trevor
Yes. The body was done on the new printer and the chassis on the old one. I'm trying something called 'ironing' in Cura which is supposed to give a smooth final layer. The van was done before I started playing with ironing. I'm not sure I've got the settings right for ironing as the finish is sometimes worse than without it.

Rik

[philipy]

I'm trying something called 'ironing' in Cura which is supposed to give a smooth final layer. The van was done before I started playing with ironing. I'm not sure I've got the settings right for ironing as the finish is sometimes worse than without it.

I always leave 'ironing' on and I think it does give a better finish where there are largish flat top surfaces, but if the top is a small area it doesn't seem to be noticeable. It doesn't do anything for angles or vertical surfaces, or for intermediate flat areas. I've been playing with an open wagon body recently but even with ironing on, the wagon floor is still showing print striations.
As I'm sure you know, it works by running a second pass over the final layer with the nozzle heat on but no filament being ejected. This just lightly re-fuses the final layer and evens out the striations. I think it works best with an increased number of top layers and/or higher infill %. If the number of layers is low then some of the heat of that ironing pass gets to heat up the trapped air inside and with the surface hot, 'pillowing' occurs.

[Trevor Thompson]

I am making good progress with the station building. The roof panels are printing well so far. The triangular profile of the lower edge of the slates is (as far as I can tell from photos) pretty close to the shape of the original slates.

So three views of the roof so far:

IMG_1062.jpg (430.4 KiB) Viewed 3936 times

IMG_1063.jpg (402.42 KiB) Viewed 3936 times

IMG_1064.jpg (315.17 KiB) Viewed 3936 times

There will be ridge tiles to go over the ridges of the roof - so I am ignoring the slight gaps along the ridge.

I am particularly pleased with the roof on the porch.

Trevor

[philipy]

An FR-ish Tipper because I drew it up from photos not actual drawings and I know some bits aren't quite right.
However, first the kit of 3D printed parts:

DSC_0001[1].jpg (160.88 KiB) Viewed 3899 times

The real thing:

0848-04-01-11-2.jpg (232.14 KiB) Viewed 3899 times

DSC_0005.jpg (144.26 KiB) Viewed 3899 times

1602785021580blob.jpg (75.41 KiB) Viewed 3899 times

DSC_0003.jpg (153.99 KiB) Viewed 3899 times

[Trevor Thompson]

That is VERY nice!

Trevor

[philipy]

Cheers Trevor.
I'm not very happy with the body, tbh. I tried to be too clever by slowing down the print speed AND increasing the minimum layer time, and ended up making the striation effect worse! Still I know what to do ( NOT to do) next time.

[Trevor Thompson]

The station roof is still printing.

Another 6 panels printed and the second roof glued into position:

IMG_1070.jpg (364.35 KiB) Viewed 3749 times

I have also started to add the stonework details to the chimney using a Bromley Crafts mylar template and wall tile adhesive. I have added black acrylic paint to the adhesive to make ir a dark gray:

IMG_1069.jpg (338.67 KiB) Viewed 3749 times

And the last roof is printing out - in 4 sections.

I am starting to think about ridge tiles and window frames.

[ge_rik]

An FR-ish Tipper because I drew it up from photos not actual drawings and I know some bits aren't quite right.
However, first the kit of 3D printed parts

Well that looks pretty darned good to me......

Rik

[ge_rik]

The station roof is still printing.

Another 6 panels printed and the second roof glued into position:

I have also started to add the stonework details to the chimney using a Bromley Crafts mylar template and wall tile adhesive. I have added black acrylic paint to the adhesive to make ir a dark gray:

And the last roof is printing out - in 4 sections.

I am starting to think about ridge tiles and window frames.

Those roof tiles look the biz! This is the sort of thing that 3D printers do well, which would be tricky to do otherwise

Rik

[Andrew]

There's some very impressive work going on here. Love the chimney stack and accurately-shaped tiles on the station building, and the tipper really captures the (pleasingly quirky) look of the real thing.

Nice that they're on the same thread too - the tippers are currently at Beamish, I believe, but I wonder how many times they'd have trundled past that station building "back in the day"?

Andrew